The Fall of Interpretation: Philosophical Foundations for a Creational Hermeneutic
Many philosophers of the past century have focused on the problem of hermeneutics. Theologians have shared this concern because of their interest in interpreting biblical texts. As postmodern critics have challenged the possibility of understanding any texts, the issue of how to respond has become acute.
Among myriad approaches to hermeneutics, both secular and Christian theorists have often assumed the same thing: that the need for interpretation is a lamentable, scandalous, even fallen affair. In an ideal world there would be no need for interpretation, since communication would be immediate, instantaneous and errorless.
James K. A. Smith, in this provocative book, cogently surveys contemporary hermeneutical discussion, identifying three traditions and how they understand interpretation. Traditional evangelicals Rex Koivisto and Richard Lints represent a present immediacy model. Wolfhart Pannenberg, Hans-Georg Gadamer and Jargen Habermas represent an eschatological immediacy model. And Martin Heidegger and Jacques Derrida represent a violent mediation model.
Questioning the foundational assumption that these secular and religious theories share, Smith deftly draws on and reworks Augustine's biblical understanding of the goodness of creation to propose a creational-pneumatic model of hermeneutics. In his words, such a hermeneutic "would link (Augustine's) insights on the temporality of human be-ing and language with his affirmation of the fundamental goodness creation: the result is an understanding of the status of interpretation as a 'creational task, ' a task which is constitutive of fortitude and thus not a 'labor' to be escaped or overcome. Such an 'interpretation ofinterpretation' revalues embodiment and ultimately ends in a ethical respect for difference as the gift of a creating God who loves difference and loves differently".
What people are saying - Write a review
Review: The Fall of the Interpretation: Philosophical Foundations for a Creational HermeneuticUser Review - Jacob Aitken - Goodreads
Smith pleads for an affirmation of finitude and temporality in understanding interpretation, and the need to return to both. Smith highlights his claim against the common evangelical desire to "get to ... Read full review
Review: The Fall of the Interpretation: Philosophical Foundations for a Creational HermeneuticUser Review - Mark Alan - Goodreads
I feel he starts marvelously here, but did not finish with the bang I was expecting. Read full review
The Beauty of the Infinite: The Aesthetics of Christian Truth
David Bentley Hart
Limited preview - 2004
Interpretation fie the Pall
On the Categories Creation and Fall
In the Beginning
The Fallenness of the Everyday
Reading the New Testament Otherwise Than Heidegger
Toward a Creational Hermeneutic
Tbward a Creational Hermeneutic
The Ethics of Interpretation
A Hermeneutics of Fallenness