Between Heaven and Hell: Islam, Salvation, and the Fate of Others
Mohammad Hassan Khalil
OUP USA, Jan 31, 2013 - Religion - 335 pages
A recent Pew survey of American Muslims found that the majority (56 percent) believed that "many religions" can lead to Paradise; only one-third held that Islam "is the one, true faith leading to eternal life." Ours is a world of ever-increasing interconnectedness. More and more Muslims today work with, befriend, and marry non-Muslims. It is perhaps not surprising, then, that a significant number of American Muslims would choose to believe that God will save their Christian parents, Jewish spouses, Buddhist neighbors, Hindu friends, or even atheist coworkers. The essays in this volume look at the views of Muslim theologians on this matter. Most maintain that while faith in the fundamental doctrines of Islam is theoretically required for salvation, God will excuse non-Muslims who never encountered the divine message conveyed by the Prophet Muhammad. (Whether such "unreached" non-Muslims still exist is the subject of much debate.) Some go a step further, and hold that God may redeem non-Muslims who were never exposed to the message in a manner that could prompt contemplation and encourage conversion. A third group of theologians-not the kind typically found at major Islamic seminaries and universities-argues that God may even save and reward non-Muslims who had a "compelling" encounter with the Islamic message yet chose to remain outside the fold. The diverse advocates of this last approach face a daunting task: demonstrating that their seemingly modern doctrine is compatible with the Islamic ethos. In recent years, considerable attention has been devoted to this debate, and indeed the larger question of non-Muslim salvation. How one regards the Other undoubtedly affects how one interacts with the Other: Should I marry her? Should I call him to the faith? Should I pray for her even though she passed away without ever converting to my religion? Should we establish missions? Should we show our love to Others to encourage rectification, or, given that their path is crooked, should we shun them? Between Heaven and Hell is intended to foster appreciation for the diverse and novel approaches taken by scholars of Islam when addressing the consequential topic of soteriology (the discourse and doctrines of salvation) and the fate of Others.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
Abdolkarim Soroush abrogation adherents affirm Ahmad al-Bukhāri al-Dîn al-fiqh al-Ghazālī al-Islām al-Kutub al-‘Ilmiyya al-Qaradawi al-Qarāfī Alī Allāh argues argument Ashk Dahlén Beirut believe Book Cairo chapter Christian claim conception contemporary context Coptic Copts damnation Dār discourse discussion divine doctrine Egyptian eternal ethical exclusivism exclusivist faith Farid Esack follow gious God’s hadith Hell hermeneutical historical human Ibid Ibn Ḥazm īmān Indonesia intercession interpretation Islamic law Islamic theology issue Jewish Jews kāfir Kitāb kuffār kufr Legenhausen means medieval mercy Messenger Mohammad Mojtahed Shabestari monotheistic moral Mu‘tazilī Muhammad ibn mushrik Muslim non-Muslims notion obligation one’s path pluralist political position practical prayer Prophet punishment question Qur’an Qur’anic verses reason reject religion religious command religious diversity religious pluralism revelation Sahih Sahih Muslim salvation scholars scripture Shah-Kazemi sharh Sharia Shi‘i soteriological specific Suha Taji-Farouki Sunni tawḥīd Tehran theologians theological tion tolerance tradition trans truth unbelievers understanding Yusuf al-Qaradawi