Equal Freedom: Selected Tanner Lectures on Human Values
Stephen L. Darwall
University of Michigan Press, 1995 - Political Science - 400 pages
and libertarian are frequently seen as opposing political labels. These two views and their oppositions are the topic of this collection of important essays by an exceptionally distinguished group of thinkers. Each was originally given as one of the lectures in the Tanner Lectures on Human Values series. This collection of essays can be read as a critique of libertarianism. A libertarian, in contemporary discussion, is one who supports no more than a minimal state-a government that protects individuals from assault, murder, theft, and other invasions of their "Lockean" rights but otherwise does not interfere with voluntary economic or personal activity. Egalitarian, on the other hand, generally refers to someone who is prepared to favor such interference if it is necessary to reduce substantial inequalities of certain kinds and if, perhaps, it is democratically authorized. Several of the essays, those of John Rawls, T. M. Scanlon, G. A. Cohen, and Ronald Dworkin, advance different versions of this liberal egalitarian line of argument. Each maintains that the ideas of freedom and equality are part of a fundamental justificatory ideal from which any rights-specifying norms, including those of libertarianism, would have to be derived. Each proposes a distinctive vision of this fundamental ideal. And each argues, on this basis, for egalitarian moral or political principles. Amartya Sen's essay can also be placed within a broadly liberal egalitarian tradition, although it is less an argument for substantive equality (and against libertarianism) than a discussion of what form a reasonable egalitarianism might take. Quentin Skinner directly criticizes libertarianism in ways that arguably tend to support egalitarianism, although this is not his primary aim.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
The Paradoxes of Political Liberty
The Significance of Choice
The Basic Liberties and Their Priority
Foundations of Liberal Equality
Equality of What?
Incentives Inequality and Community
Other editions - View all
accept achieve action appropriate argue argument basic liberties believe better capacity challenge choice circumstances citizens claim conception concern consider constitutional convictions cooperation course critical depend determinate difference principle discussion distinction distribution economic effect ends equality ethical example exercise explain fact fair follows force freedom give given grounds human idea impact important incentive individual inequalities institutions interests interpretation justify kind lead least less liberal liberal equality limits lives matter means moral nature notion objective original particular parties person perspective philosophical political position possible preferences premise present principles of justice priority problem protect question rational Rawls reason reflection reject responsibility result rich seems sense significance social society speech suggestion talented theory things thought tion true University utilitarianism utility well-being