How to Justify Torture: Inside the Ticking Bomb Scenario
From Batman Begins to Tom Clancy, How to Justify Torture shows how contemporary culture creates simplified narratives about good guy torturers and bad guy victims, how dangerous this is politically, and what we can do to challenge it.
If there was a bomb hidden somewhere in a major city, and you had the person responsible in your custody, would you torture them to get the information needed to stop the bomb exploding, preventing a devastating terrorist attack and saving thousands of lives?
This is the ticking bomb scenario -- a thought experiment designed to demonstrate that torture can be justified.
In How to Justify Torture, cultural critic Alex Adams examines the ticking bomb scenario in-depth, looking at the ways it is presented in films, novels, and TV shows -- from Batman Begins and Dirty Harry to French military thrillers and home invasion narratives. By critiquing its argument step by step, this short, provocative book reminds us that, despite what the ticking bomb scenario will have us believe, torture can never be justified.
What people are saying - Write a review
We haven't found any reviews in the usual places.
Other editions - View all
Alan Dershowitz argues atrocity audience Batman Captain America Centurions character Christopher Nolan claim Clancy comic book committed common sense counterterrorism crime criminal Criminology critique Daredevil Dark Knight Death Wish Dirty Hands Dirty Harry Dirty Harry problem effective emergency Episode ethical evil example fiction Film force framed harm Harry’s human rights idea ideological innocent interrogation Jack Bauer Jair Bolsonaro Jean Lartéguy Jon Cassar Journal justice justification for torture justified Lartéguy’s Lee Hurst legalistic legitimate London Luke Cage masculinity means moral movie murder novel NYPD Blue obvious Oxford Penguin philosophical police political Popular Culture prevent prisoner protagonist protect Punisher question representations represented rescue responsible reveal situation Terrorism terrorist texts thought experiment thriller ticking bomb narratives ticking bomb scenario ticking bomb torture torture torture is shown torture scene trans trolley problem Trump University Press utilitarian argument victim vigilante villain violence War on Terror waterboarding York