Ethics and Mental Retardation

Front Cover
L.M. Kopelman, J.C. Moskop
Springer Science & Business Media, Feb 29, 1984 - Medical - 258 pages
This volume offers a collection of writings on ethical issues regarding retarded persons. Because this important subject has been generally omitted from formal discussions of ethics, there is a great deal which needs to be addressed in a theoretical and critical way. Of course, many people have been very concerned with practical matters concerning the care of retarded persons such as what liberties, entitlements or advocacy they should have. Interestingly, because so much practical attention has been given to issues which are not discussed by ethical theorists, they offer a rare opportunity to evaluate ethical theories themselves. That is, certain theories which appear convincing on other subjects seem implausible when they are applied to reasoned and com pelling views we hold concerning retarded individuals. Our subject, then, has both practical and conceptual dimensions. More over, because it is one where pertinent information comes from many sources, contributors to this volume represent many fields, including philosophy, religion, history, law and medicine. We regret that it was not possible to include more points of view, like those of psychologists, sociologists, nurses and families. There is however, a good and longstanding literature on mental retardation from these perspectives.
 

Contents

Rights and Borderline Cases
3
Applying Moral Theory to the Retarded
19
Joseph Margolis John Rawls and the Mentally Retarded
37
Do the Retarded Have a Right Not to Be Eaten? A Rejoinder to Joseph Margolis
43
The Rights of the Retarded
47
Rights Justice and the Retarded
57
Issues of Valuing and Labeling
65
A Reply to Loretta Kopelman
87
Two Theological Views
161
Responses to William F May and John C Moskop
177
The Legal Rights of Mentally Retarded Persons in Twentieth Century America
185
Examining Legal Restrictions on the Retarded
209
Who Speaks for the Retarded?
223
Commentary on David J Rothmans Who Speaks for the Retarded?
235
Dilemmas in the Neonatal Intensive Care Unit
243
Health Care Needs and Rights of Retarded Persons
247

Labeling the Mentally Retarded
99
A Reply to Laurence B Mccullough
119
Must God Create the Best?
127
Parenting Bonding and Valuing the Retarded
141
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
253
INDEX
255
Copyright

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

Bibliographic information