Two conflicting ideas of reformation Charles v. and Ducal Saxony and Electoral Brandenburg become Protestant 377 BOOK I. ON THE EVE OF THE REFORMATION. CHAPTER L THE PAPACY.1 § 1. Claim to Universal Supremacy. THE long struggle between the Medieval Church and the Mediæval Empire, between the priest and the warrior,2 ended, in the earlier half of the thirteenth century, in the overthrow of the Hohenstaufens, and left the Papacy sole inheritor of the claim of ancient Rome to be sovereign of the civilised world. Roma caput mundi regit orbis frena rotundi. 1 SOURCES: Apparatus super quinque libris decretalium (Strassburg, 1488); Burchard, Diarium (ed. by Thuasne, Paris, 1883-1885), in 3 vols. ; Brand, Narrenschiff (ed. by Simrock, Berlin, 1872); Denzinger, Enchiridion Symbolorum et Definitionum, quæ de rebus fidei et morum a conciliis œcumenicis et summis pontificibus, emanarunt (Würzburg, 1900), 9th ed.; Erler, Der Liber Cancellaria Apostolica vom Jahre 1480 (Leipzig, 1888); Faber, Tractatus de Ruine Ecclesie Planctu (Memmingen); Murner, Schelmenzunft and Narrenbeschwörung (Nos. 85, 119-124 of Neudrucke deutschen Litteraturwerke); Mirbt, Quellen zur Geschichte des Papsttums (Freiburg i. B. 1895); Tangl, Die päpstlichen Kanzleiordnungen von 1200-1500 (Innsbruck, 1894); and Das Taxwesen der päpstlichen Kirche (Mitt. des Instituts für österreichische Geschichtsforschung, xiii. 1892). LATER BOOKS: "Janus," The Pope and the Council (London, 1869); Harnack, History of Dogma (London, 1899), vols. vi. vii.; Thudichen, Papsttum und Reformation (Leipzig, 1903); Haller, Papsttum und KirchenReform (1903); Lea, Cambridge Modern History (Cambridge, 1902), vol. I. xix. "In hac (sc. ecclesia) ejusque potestate duos esse gladios, spiritualem videlicet et temporalem, evangelicis dictis instruimur. . . . Ille sacerdotis, is manu regum et militum, sed ad nutum et patienciam sacerdotis"; Boniface VIII. in the Bull, Unam Sanctam. Strong and masterful Popes had for centuries insisted on exercising powers which, they asserted, belonged to them as the successors of St. Peter and the representatives of Christ upon earth. Ecclesiastical jurists had translated their assertions into legal language, and had expressed them in principles borrowed from the old imperial law. Precedents, needed by the legal mind to unite the past with the present, had been found in a series of imaginary papal judgments extending over past centuries. The forged decretals of the pseudo-Isidor (used by Pope Nicholas I. in his letter of 866 A.D. to the bishops of Gaul), of the group of canonists who supported the pretensions of Pope Gregory VII. (1073-1085),-Anselm of Lucca, Deusdedit, Cardinal Bonzio, and Gregory of Pavia,-gave to the papal claims the semblance of the sanction of antiquity. The Decretum of Gratian, issued in 1150 from Bologna, then the most famous Law School in Europe, incorporated all these earlier forgeries and added new ones. It displaced the older collections of Canon Law and became the starting-point for succeeding canonists. Its mosaic of facts and falsehoods formed the basis for the theories of the imperial powers and of the universal jurisdiction of the Bishops of Rome.1 The picturesque religious background of this conception of the Church of Christ as a great temporal empire had been furnished by St. Augustine, although probably he would have been the first to protest against the use made of his vision of the City of God. His unfinished masterpiece, De Civitate Dei, in which with a devout and glowing imagination he had contrasted the Civitas Terrena, or the secular State founded on conquest and maintained by fraud and violence, with the Kingdom of God, which he identified. with the visible ecclesiastical society, had filled the imagination of all Christians in the days immediately preceding the dissolution of the Roman Empire of the West, and had contributed in a remarkable degree to the 1 A succinct account of these forgeries will be found in "Janus,' The Pope and the Council (London, 1869), p. 94. final overthrow of the last remains of a cultured paganism. It became the sketch outline which the jurists of the Roman Curia gradually filled in with details by their strictly defined and legally expressed claim of the Roman Pontiff to a universal jurisdiction. Its living but poetically indefinite ideas were transformed into clearly defined legal principles found ready-made in the all-embracing jurisprudence of the ancient empire, and were analysed and exhibited in definite claims to rule and to judge in every department of human activity. When poetic thoughts, which from their very nature stretch forward towards and melt in the infinite, are imprisoned within legal formulas and are changed into principles of practical jurisprudence, they lose all their distinctive character, and the creation which embodies them becomes very different from what it was meant to be. The mischievous activity of the Roman canonists actually transformed the Civitas Dei of the glorious vision of St. Augustine into that Civitas Terrena which he reprobated, and the ideal Kingdom of God became a vulgar earthly monarchy, with all the accompaniments of conquest, fraud, and violence which, according to the great theologian of the West, naturally belonged to such a society. But the glamour of the City of God long remained to dazzle the eyes of gifted and pious men during the earlier Middle Ages, when they contemplated the visible ecclesiastical empire ruled by the Bishop of Rome. The requirements of the practical religion of everyday life were also believed to be in the possession of this ecclesiastical monarchy to give and to withhold. For it was the almost universal belief of medieval piety that the mediation of a priest was essential to salvation; and the priesthood was an integral part of this monarchy, and did not exist outside its boundaries. "No good Catholic Christian doubted that in spiritual things the clergy were the divinely appointed superiors of the laity, that this power proceeded from the right of the priests to celebrate the sacraments, that the Pope was the real possessor of |