Preventing the Future: Why was Ireland So Poor for So Long?

Front Cover
Gill & Macmillan, 2005 - History - 340 pages

Between the years of the mid thirties through to 1960, independent Ireland suffered from economic stagnation, and also went through a period of intense cultural and psychological repression. While external circumstances account for much of the stagnation - especially the depression of the thirties and the Second World War - Preventing the Future argues that the situation was aggravated by internal circumstances.

The key domestic factor was the failure to extend higher and technical education and training to larger sections of the population. This derived from political stalemates in a small country which derived in turn from the power of the Catholic Church, the strength of the small-farm community, the ideological wish to preserve an older society and, later, gerontocratic tendencies in the political elites and in society as a whole.

While economic growth did accelerate after 1960, the political stand-off over mass education resulted in large numbers of young people being denied preparation for life in the modern world and, arguably, denied Ireland a sufficient supply of trained labour and educated citizens. Ireland's Celtic Tiger of the nineties was in great part driven by a new and highly educated and technically trained workforce. The political stalemates of the forties and fifties delayed the initial, incomplete take-off until the sixties and resulted in the Tiger arriving nearly a generation later than it might have.


'Make no mistake about it, this is an academic page turner and as provocative a read as it is scholarly and challenging. Tom Garvin, using his accomplished and characteristic combination of history and political science, sets out to discuss the simple question: why was Ireland so poor for so long? ... Reading Tom Garvin's book would make a good start on the road to developing a deeper sense of citizenship ... It may come to be regarded as a classic of its kind. It ought to be required reading ... if only to show that the slowness of Irish development was substantially a self-inflicted but not fatal wound, which can't be blamed on the British empire or, for that matter, the Rolling Stones. We did it our way.' - Dermot Keogh, The Irish Times

'Seventy years ago science was made optional in primary schools to allow more time for the Irish language - even though many of the pupils could hardly read English. The state deliberately neglected technical education, with the Education Minister in the early 1950s stating that, after religious formation, the "inculcation of patriotism is the second great goal of education." These are just some of the stunning observations that tumble off every page in this great book.' - Joe Duffy, RTE broadcaster

From inside the book

What people are saying - Write a review

LibraryThing Review

User Review  - thegeneral - LibraryThing

Like Garvin's other books this one is also well researched, written and argued. Initially Garvin indicates that to get to the bottom of identifying why Ireland was so poor for so long it is overtly ... Read full review


Politics and Development in Ireland
Agonising Reappraisal

4 other sections not shown

Other editions - View all

Common terms and phrases

About the author (2005)

Tom Garvin is Emeritus Professor of Politics at University College Dublin and an honorary research fellow at IBIS. His books include Nationalist Revolutionaries inIreland (1987), 1922: The Birth of Irish Democracy (1996), and Preventing theFuture:Why was Ireland so poor for so long? (2004). He is also the author of many articles and chapters on Irish and comparative politics. He is an alumnus of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars, Washington D.C., and a Member of the Royal Irish Academy. He has taught at the University of Georgia, Colgate University and Mount Holyoke College. Most recently, his biography of Seán Lemass, Judging Lemass, was published by the Royal Irish Academy in 2009.

Bibliographic information