Deception and Detection in Eighteenth-century Britain
In the first extended treatment of the debates surrounding public deception in eighteenth-century Britain, Jack Lynch contends that forgery, and fraud make explicit the usually unspoken grounds on which Britons made sense of their world. Confrontations with inauthenticity, in other words, bring tacitly understood conceptions of reality to the surface.Drawing on a wide range of contemporary print and manuscript sources - not only books and pamphlets, but ballads, comic prints, legal proceedings, letters, and diaries - Lynch focuses on the debates they provoked, rather than the forgers themselves. He offers a comprehensive treatment of the criticism surrounding fraud in most of the noteworthy controversies of the long eighteenth century. To this end, his study is structured around topics related to the arguments over deception in Britain, whether they concerned George Psalmanazar's Formosan hoax at the beginning of the eighteenth century or William Henry Ireland's Shakespearean imposture at the end.Beginning with the question of what constitutes deception and ending with an illuminating chapter on what was at stake in these debates for eighteenth-century British thinkers, Lynch's accessibly written study takes the reader through the means - whether simple, sophisticated, or tortuously argued - by which partisans on both sides struggled to define which of the apparent contradictions were sufficient to disqualify a claim to authenticity. Fakery, Lynch persuasively argues, transports us to the heart of eighteenth-century notions of the value of evidence, of the mechanisms of perception and memory, of the relationship between art and life, of historicism, and of human motivation.
admitted anachronism ancient Anna Seward antiquity argues argument authenticity believe Bentham best evidence rule BL Add Blair Boswell Canning's century character Chatterton circumstantial evidence claims consistent contradict convinced counterfeit critics debates deception discussion Dissertation documents doubt Edmond Malone eighteenth eighteenth-century Britain Elizabeth English Enquiry epic epistemic probability Essay fact fake fakers false fiction Fingal forgery Fragments fraud genius Gentleman's Magazine genuine George Psalmanazar Highlands human Hume Ibid imposture inconsistencies insists James Macpherson John knowledge language Lauder least letter literary Macpherson Malone Malone's manuscript Mary Toft modern motive narrative nature never oral tradition original Ossianic poems Percy person Poems of Ossian poet poetry principle probability Psalmanazar published question readers Rowleian Rowley Rowley's Samuel Ireland Samuel Johnson Scotland Seward Shakespeare Shaw skepticism story supposed Temora testimony things Thomas Thomas Chatterton Thomas Warton truth Walpole Warton William William Henry Ireland words writes wrote