Click on a thumbnail to go to Google Books.
Loading... God Against The Gods: The History of the War Between Monotheism and Polytheism (original 2004; edition 2005)by Jonathan KirschThere was some interesting information in there, but most of it I already knew. I also felt there just wasn't enough information most of the time. To top it off, it should really have had a subtitle about how it focuses almost solely on the Western world, and the Roman one in particular. I was really hoping there would be some information about, for example, Arabian polytheism and those peoples' conversion to Islam. But they barely even get a mention, which was disappointing. And what about the combination of colonization and conversion to monotheism that went on in many African and South American countries? Nothing. Although a serviceable account of the struggle between polytheism and monotheism in the Mediterranean region, principally from the time of Josiah to the death of Julian, the books cover promises more than the text delivers. This reader was disappointed that Kirsch did not address directly the question as to why Christianity, a minority religion, triumphed over paganism so quickly after the death of Julian. The author mentions, almost in passing, that Roman emperors had totalitarian powers as if that was an obvious and inarguable explanation for the phenomenon without demonstrating that it was true or why it inevitably led to the effective end of monotheism. A superficial and boring account of monotheism and polytheism in antiquity. It doesn't even come close to living up to its fancy title. The book contains miscellaneous historical anecdotes but not any serious or original historical research. The author fails to put his strange mixture of stories into a broader perspective. Kirsch writes on a terribly important subject, if only he would keep his focus upon it. The first half or so of God against the Gods is an eye-opening exploration of the differences and conflicts between monotheistic and polytheistic religions, and certainly concludes that the polytheists, while not perfect, were on the whole *far* more tolerant and far less murderous than the Abrahamic religions that sought to eradicate them. Almost equally valuable is the history lesson Kirsch provides, weaving threads of connection between the monotheism we understand today and its probable birth in ancient Egypt. We learn particularly about the somewhat final showdown in Rome between Christians (Constantine and descendants) and pagans (Julian).If only it were so. Though a fascinating read in and of itself, the book becomes a kind of historical narrative about Constantine-era political intrigue. Yes, the religious aspect is central, but the book careens from an overview of the conflict between two theologies to a truncated history book on the bloody chess game played between Roman Augusti and Caesars. I would love to read that book, but not here. Certainly there was more to explore beyond Julian concerning mono-vs.-polytheism, even into the modern world. Why stop so short?In all, a worthwhile read, though expect to go somewhat off track halfway through. Even though God Against the Gods bills itself as covering vast swaths of the history of religion, most of the book is dedicated to exploring the transition of the Roman empire from paganism to Christianity under Constantine and his heirs. And surprisingly, it was neither a smooth nor complete transition, and Rome certainly could've swung back the other way. Kirsch's writing is probably the roughest part of this book - he's a journalist, not a scholar, and sometimes he does the snappy, too-clever-by-half journalist writing. And I wish that he would've put forth a stronger thesis at the beginning of the book that would've guided his argument better; too often it read as a straightforward history book that didn't intend to come to a point (although he does tie things together at the end). Nevertheless, it was an interesting book that synthesized a lot of different materials about religion in the Roman empire. Excellent work. This is an analysis, first of the development and growth of monotheism as it existed from its first Egyptian roots through Judaism and finally Christianity. It explains the differences between the rigiorist monotheism of those schools, with the accepting, diversity that was a part of pagan Rome. The second half of the book provides a thorough understanding of the reasons and methods that the diversity of paganism lost its cultural battle with the radical monothiesm of Christianity in the reigns of Constantine and Julius. Excellent information, and analysis. This is an accessibly written, entertaining history of the struggle between monotheism and polytheism. Kirsch goes a long way to remove misconceptions about paganism that centuries of Christian rhetoric have obscured. The book covers the development of early monotheistic ideas (Including an interesting thought that the monotheistic worship of Aten, the sun god, as initiated by the Egyptian pharaoh Ahkenaten, may have been the origins of Jewish monotheism, as certain people fled the kingdom when Ahkenaten died and the area reverted to polytheism. As it’s explained, Ahkenaten’s monotheism is the first recorded instance of such a thing, so it isn’t unlikely.) and in the second half, concentrates on Constantine, who of course established monotheistic Christianity as a state religion, and one of his successors, Julian, who attempted a last ditch effort to restore paganism after him. His conclusion is perfect, and striking, Though this is part of the last sentence of the book, it also serves as a great teaser to those who haven't read it regarding the promise of the content within: "...we might pause and ponder how the world would have turned out if the war of God against the gods had ended with an armistice rather than the victory of the Only True God." |
Current DiscussionsNonePopular covers
Google Books — Loading... GenresMelvil Decimal System (DDC)291.14Religions Other Religions Comparative Religion; Mythology (No Longer Used) Mythologies Categories of ReligionLC ClassificationRatingAverage:
Is this you?Become a LibraryThing Author. |